The Market Has Hit the Moment of Maximum Indecision

The Market Has Hit the Moment of Maximum Indecision
By Jeff Clark
October 1, 2009

It's a bull market. No, wait, it's a bear market. Nope, bull... no again, bear.

Since the beginning of this remarkable seven-month rally, I've been arguing it's only a bear-market rally. Bear markets unfold in three distinct trends. And while the severity of the first downtrend was intense and more destructive than anything any of us have seen in our lifetimes, there are still two more downtrends to go.

But I was willing to concede defeat if the bulls could rally the S&P 500 decisively above 1,055 by the end of September.

You see, 1,055 is the level of the 20-month exponential moving average (EMA) for the S&P 500. For the past 25 years, I've used this 20-month EMA as the defining point for bull and bear markets. And it's never failed me.

If the S&P is trading above the blue line, then stocks are in a bull market. If the index is below the blue line, then the bear is in control.

In January 2008, the monthly chart of the S&P 500 dropped below its 20-month exponential moving average, and a bear market was born. Yesterday, the index closed 0.25% above the monthly EMA. Here's the chart...

A monthly close of 1% or 2% above the line is enough to coax me to throw in the towel and regretfully eat the pile of crow that has been building up in front of me over the past few months. In fact, as the market rallied early yesterday morning, I was frantically looking for something that could possibly justify explaining a switch from bearish to bullish after such a prolonged period.

But a 0.25% close above the line? Heck, that's a rounding error. In fact, the first bounce during the bear market of 2001 closed ever so slightly above the line. The S&P then went on to lose more than 40% over the next 20 months.

I can't find any reason to be bullish here. Yes, I know stocks are going up. But they're not going up because the underlying fundamentals justify the move. They're going up because institutional money managers feel pressured to follow the crowd and chase performance. Otherwise, they'll have to explain their subpar gains over the past quarter.

Their buying is creating demand at the same time the bearish traders are too whipped to hit them with aggressive selling pressure.

Still, as a trader and a follower of technical analysis (with some fundamental stuff thrown in for good measure), I'd have to respect a decisive breakout above the line. But it didn't happen.

The S&P 500 closed right at the point of maximum indecision. Bears and bulls alike can make equally compelling arguments. So we have to look at the intermediate-term indicators to get a better idea of the impending trend.

The most reliable indicators I use are the Nasdaq and NYSE Summation Indexes. Both of those crossed to the downside yesterday, generating sell signals.

Why Stocks Are Moving Higher

What the Best Traders I Know Are Telling Me

The old Wall Street saying, "the market will do whatever is necessary to make the most people look like morons" is coming true. Bulls can point to the monthly close of the S&P 500 above its 20-month EMA to reassert their stance. Bears can point to the obvious resistance at this level and the sell signals from the intermediate-term indicators to enforce their positions.

The market has done a bang-up job on the bears over the past few weeks. Perhaps it's finally time to take a shot at the bulls.

Best regards and good trading,

Jeff Clark

PIMCO's Bill Gross no longer worried about inflation
Buying Treasuries to protect against deflation...

Elite money manager says get out of financials and into these sectors
Agrees with PIMCO's Gross on the economy's "new normal."

How to invest when you're flat broke
Ideas for getting started without much cash...

•	10-year Treasury hits 3.29%... down from 3.89% in August.
•	Gold pops back over $1,000... still below all-time highs.
•	Boom in Brazil continues... Petroleo Brasileiro, Brasil Telecom, Banco Bradesco, and fund EWZ hit new highs.
•	Earnings today... Accenture, Constellation Brands.

	Last	Change	52-Wk
S&P 500	1062.98	+1.78%	-12.37%
Oil (USO)	34.51	+1.50%	-59.97%
Gold (GLD)	97.05	+0.05%	+12.02%
Silver (SLV)	15.91	+1.08%	+20.99%
U.S. Dollar	77.11	+0.26%	-0.52%
Euro	1.46	-0.40%	+0.97%
VIX	24.88	-2.85%	-28.38%
HUI	398.09	+0.10%	+20.93%
10-Year Yield	3.30%	-0.03	-0.46

Advertisement

Company	Sym	Industry
Wyeth	WYE	Big Pharma
Kohl's	KSS	dept stores
Mechel OAO	MTL	steel
Joy Global	JOYG	machinery
Nuance Comm	NUAN	software
Wyndham	WYN	hotels
TransDigm	TDG	defense
Concur Tech	CNQR	systems software
Westpac	WBK	bank
Korea Electric	KEP	utilities
Vivo Parti	VIV	wireless telecom
Illumina	ILMN	biotech
EXCO Resources	XCO	oil & gas drilling
James Hardie	JHX	building products
Biovail	BVF	drug delivery
Dril-Quip	DRQ	oil & gas svcs
Unilever	UL	packaged goods
ICICI Bank	IBN	bank
AES Corporation	AES	utilities
Everest Re	RE	insurance
Windstream	WIN	telecom
Telecom Argentina	TEO	telecom
Harman Intl	HAR	electronics
Cadence Design	CDNS	systems software
Petroleo Brasileiro	PBR	oil & gas drilling
Wipro	WIT	outsourcing
Turkcell	TKC	wireless telecom
Comp Brasileira	CBD	grocery stores
LAN Airlines	LFL	airlines
Sybase	SY	software
Jabil Circuit	JBL	circuit boards
Williams-Sonoma	WSM	home furnishings
Itau Unibanco	ITUB	bank
Siderurgica Nacl	SID	steel
Sterlite Industries	SLT	copper
Credicorp	BAP	bank
Och-Ziff Capital	OZM	asset mgmt
F5 Networks	FFIV	networks
Hospitality Prop	HPT	retail REIT
Endurance Spec	ENH	insurance
AMBEV	ABV	beer
HDFC Bank	HDB	bank
Amerisource	ABC	pharma
Virgin Media	VMED	TV systems
Rovi	ROVI	graphics software
Allscripts-Misys	MDRX	health IT
Valeant Pharma	VRX	pharma
MarkWest Energy	MWE	oil & gas drilling
Banco Bradesco	BBD	bank
KB Financial	KB	bank
Fairfax Financial	FFH	insurance
Brasil Telecom	BTM	telecom
NET Servicos	NETC	TV systems
Nalco Holding	NLC	synthetics
Acergy	ACGY	oil & gas svcs
CorpBanca	BCA	bank

Company	Sym	Industry
UCBH Holdings	UCBH	bank
Array BioPharma	ARRY	medical research
Osiris Therapeutics	OSIR	biotech
Hampton Roads	HMPR	bank
Pacific Capital	PCBC	bank
Nobel Learning	NLCI	for-profit ed

Commodity Q&A: The Best One-Click Ways to Own Precious Metals
September 30, 2009

How to Know When to Buy Gold Stocks
September 29, 2009

How to Turn a 100% Gain into a 1,400% Gain
September 28, 2009

Weekend Edition: Hundreds of Percent Gains in Housing
September 26, 2009

Big Upside in this "Life or Death" Market
September 25, 2009