The Commodity Investor Q&A
With Matt Badiali
December 16, 2009
ExxonMobil recently offered to pay $32 billion for natural gas producer XTO Energy, a 25% overnight payout for XTO shareholders.
XTO Energy is one of the premier "unconventional" natural gas companies in the U.S. (We discussed unconventional gas here and here.)
Unconventional gas is trapped in shale. Shale is a sedimentary rock made of fine particles of clay and mud deposited at the bottom of ocean basins or giant lakes. The shale that oil and gas companies like has a lot of old plants and algae mixed in. Over time, that kind of shale makes natural gas and sometimes oil.
There are several premier shale plays in the U.S., like the Barnett in Texas, the Marcellus in Pennsylvania, and Haynesville in Arkansas. XTO holds leases in all of them.
Exxon's Big Oil peers began buying into shale plays years ago. Both Chevron and ConocoPhillips bought in 2005. Gas price forecasts were rising and the prices they paid reflected it. But Exxon really hasn't jumped in... until now.
Exxon is notoriously tight with its cash. That's one reason why it's hugely popular with value investors like Stansberry Research's own Dan Ferris. So did Exxon get a good deal? I think so...
Acquirer |
Acquired |
Price per MCFE* |
ExxonMobil |
XTO Energy |
$2.31 |
ConocoPhillips |
Burlington |
$4.50 |
Chevron |
Unocal |
$3.02 |
*Thousand cubic feet of natural gas equivalent |
|
The overall outlook on natural gas is pessimistic. Basically, there's more gas in storage than we can realistically use up this winter and even more production in our future. If we don't figure out a way to use it, the glut will continue to depress prices. (You can read more on this topic here.)
So why would Exxon buy XTO now? Let's take a closer look...
Exxon's offer is $32 billion in stock. That doesn't take into consideration XTO's $10 billion in net debt. So we'll use $42 billion as the buy price.
On paper, Exxon is buying 13.8 trillion cubic feet of natural gas reserves. But XTO actually has another 14 trillion cubic feet of natural gas that it can't call reserves. The SEC defines oil and gas reserves as "economic" today. Unconventional gas is not economic until it's drilled. You have to fracture the rock to get it out. But shale wells are remarkably consistent, so we know the gas is there.
All-in, Exxon paid $42 billion for 27.8 trillion cubic feet of gas. That works out to $1.50 per MCF... about 50% lower than the recent bottom and 72% below today's prices at $5.50.
When you look at it that way, you can see how brilliant Exxon is at this stuff. Even if gas prices fall all the way down to their record lows, Exxon got a good deal... and so did XTO shareholders.
There are plenty of cheap natural gas producers out there. I put together a table of a few I think might make good buyout targets if Exxon's deal kicks off a trend...
Company |
Enterprise Value |
Price Per MCFE |
Ultra Petroleum |
$8 billion |
$2.29 |
Chesapeake Energy |
$28 billion |
$2.35 |
EOG Resources |
$25 billion |
$2.88 |
|
Enterprise value is the market cap plus debt, minus cash. It's how Exxon valued XTO. As you can see, these giant gas companies are similar to XTO by that measure. This is where I'd start looking for my next natural gas investment.
Good investing,
Matt |
|
|
| • |
Stimulus plans working... FedEx and UPS hit new highs. |
| • |
Tech fund XLK makes a new high... up 30% since July. |
| • |
Largest U.S. lumber producer surges... Weyerhauser jumps 4.2% to fresh high. |
| • |
Earnings today... Hovnanian, Joy Global, Paychex. |
|
Last |
Change |
52-Wk |
| S&P 500 |
1109.30 |
+1.45% |
+27.03% |
| Oil (USO) |
40.29 |
+2.99% |
-12.75% |
| Gold (GLD) |
111.63 |
+1.72% |
+52.29% |
| Silver (SLV) |
18.01 |
+5.01% |
+92.41% |
| U.S. Dollar |
75.37 |
+0.68% |
-13.15% |
| Euro |
1.49 |
-0.70% |
+17.54% |
| VIX |
22.89 |
-2.01% |
-65.48% |
| HUI |
475.53 |
+3.26% |
+155.07% |
| 10-Year Yield |
3.33% |
-0.10 |
-0.37 |
|
|
| Company |
Sym |
Industry |
UPS |
UPS |
air freight |
Ford |
F |
Big Auto |
Telmex |
TII |
telecom |
L-3 |
LLL |
defense |
Amerisource |
ABC |
pharma |
Waters |
WAT |
technical devices |
Equinix |
EQIX |
telecom |
J. Crew |
JCG |
clothing stores |
Oracle |
ORCL |
software |
3M |
MMM |
conglomerate |
Corning |
GLW |
telecom |
Precision |
PCP |
metal fabrication |
CBS |
CBS |
TV |
Enbridge Energy |
EEP |
pipelines |
AMD |
AMD |
semiconductors |
Walter Energy |
WLT |
coal mining |
AGL Resources |
AGL |
utilities |
Visa |
V |
credit cards |
UnitedHealth |
UNH |
health insurance |
WellPoint |
WLP |
health insurance |
Williams |
WMB |
pipelines |
Smith & Nephew |
SNN |
medical devices |
Starwood |
HOT |
hotels |
Cree |
CREE |
semiconductors |
Autoliv |
ALV |
auto parts |
Unilever |
UL |
toiletries |
Home Depot |
HD |
home goods |
FedEx |
FDX |
air freight |
Zimmer |
ZMH |
medical devices |
Bancolombia |
CIB |
bank |
Warner Chilcott |
WCRX |
pharma |
Mylan |
MYL |
pharma |
Wyndham |
WYN |
hotels |
TRW Automotive |
TRW |
auto parts |
United Tech |
UTX |
conglomerate |
News Corp |
NWSA |
entertainment |
TransCanada |
TRP |
utilities |
Quest |
DGX |
medical research |
Weyerhaeuser |
WY |
lumber |
Linear Tech |
LLTC |
semiconductors |
EXCO Resources |
XCO |
oil & gas drilling |
DreamWorks |
DWA |
movies |
Arcelor Mittal |
MT |
steel |
MasterCard |
MA |
credit cards |
Kinder Morgan |
KMP |
pipelines |
Yanzhou Coal |
YZC |
coal mining |
Rockwell Collins |
COL |
defense |
Avalonbay |
AVB |
residential REIT |
Hasbro |
HAS |
toys |
Albemarle |
ALB |
synthetics |
Walt Disney |
DIS |
entertainment |
Infosys |
INFY |
outsourcing |
Starbucks |
SBUX |
coffee |
CIGNA |
CI |
health insurance |
|
| Company |
Sym |
Industry |
China Holdings |
HOL |
acquisitions |
Princeton Review |
REVU |
for profit ed |
China Ritar |
CRTP |
electrical equip |
First Merchants |
FRME |
bank |
Omega Nav |
ONAV |
shipping |
Pantry |
PTRY |
grocery stores |
YRC Worldwide |
YRCW |
trucking |
Cypress |
CYPB |
biotech |
|
|
| Customer Service: 1-888-261-2693 – Copyright 2010 Stansberry & Associates Investment Research. All Rights Reserved. Protected by copyright laws of the United States and international treaties. This e-letter may only be used pursuant to the subscription agreement and any reproduction, copying, or redistribution (electronic or otherwise, including on the world wide web), in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited without the express written permission of Stansberry & Associates Investment Research, LLC. 1217 Saint Paul Street, Baltimore MD 21202 |
